Home discussions Sex Addiction Treatment Center And Counselor Reviews APSAT Training–What They Are Teaching

Viewing 7 posts - 26 through 32 (of 32 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #128344
    teri
    Participant

    Thanks, Diane, for the clarification. Although I think your brand of Christianity is not unfortunately what is probably considered mainstream at least here in the U.S. So I think Omar is fair if he is skeptical of even mainstream religion. I think having the label or association of Christianity in the US has become a big sign post meaning “fundamentalist only; others keep out” to many people.

    But it is important to note that there are people like you and Bev and other friends I know. I think if Christianity was associated with open minds, arms, and hearts, it might not be such an issue. Very sad.

    #128345
    joann
    Participant

    Ahhh….The Poisonwood Bible. Right up there in my all time favorites along with Gone With The Wind and Cross Creek. All of them about strong, courageous women.

    Thanks for reminding me of it Bev, it’s time to read it again. ~ JoAnn

    #128346
    diane
    Participant

    Yes, it is a great book! Tough but great!

    #128347
    meg
    Participant

    Sorry Diane sloppy was my way of saying at 11:00 pm at night – they didn’t give a fuck anymore who and how badly they destroyed – you said it much better:)

    #128348
    meg
    Participant

    Well they never cared about that – you watch APTAS purloin Omar’s perpetration model next – csats won’t wanna touch that!

    #128349
    beenthere
    Participant

    Minwalla seems very cautious as he articulates his stance for the trauma model, both as an element in the SA treatment and the partner treatment. It is essentially an activist stance, informed by his background as a sexologist first, and his seeking to honor the human rights of all people, marginalized partners, sexual minorities, LGBTQ, etc. in order to address the profound damage that male sexual privileging does to the whole world. I have a sense that his approach can be felt to be antithetical to many “mainstream” interpretations, but at the same time, in order to get traction for his research, he has to “play nice” with some people he wouldn’t ordinarily align with . I have noted since first looking at his website, for example, that he no longer has a “resources” page that recommends other people’s books. I think he is trying to draw a bright line between respecting certain aspects of traditional Carnes model for SAs, and challenging Carnes et al to move forward (which I don’t see Carnes has done at all). He is putting his money where his mouth is. Don’t legitimize someone whose stance you don’t believe in. It dilutes your message, and delegitimizes the work you are trying to do. If you don’t believe in your heart of hearts in the truth of the trauma conceptualization, then your “techniques” will be ineffective and harmful. That’s where the therapists who give lip service to partner trauma while still holding on to their co-dependency, foo god only knows what cranes inspired BS, are falling down. We see through this. Take a side, goddammit! Man UP!

    #128350
    barbra
    Member

    Been there after my experiences this week so far I agree 100 percent

Viewing 7 posts - 26 through 32 (of 32 total)
  • The forum ‘Sex Addiction Treatment Center And Counselor Reviews’ is closed to new topics and replies.